Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Fold (16-inch) review: a foldable flop

Lenovo offers a wider range of configurations than its primary competitors, with a starting price of $2,499 for a Core i5-1230U, 8GB of RAM, a 256GB SSD, and without an active pen, keyboard, or stand. It’s unusual to omit a pen on a device like this, and adding one in is a $50 option. The keyboard and stand are a $300 option.

Fully configured, the ThinkPad X1 Fold costs $4,211, with a Core i7-1260U vPro, 32GB of RAM (available only with this CPU option), a 1TB SSD, optional WWAN connectivity, an active pen, and the keyboard and stand.

The two other foldable laptops we’ve reviewed, the Asus Zenbook Fold 17 and the HP Spectre Foldable PC, are similar in design and built around roughly 17-inch foldable OLED panels. That makes the ThinkPad X1 Fold with its 16.3-inch display slightly smaller, both when folded and unfolded. I noticed the biggest difference when the ThinkPad X1 Fold was closed, making for a more compact folio-like device to tote around.

The Lenovo is also heavier when the keyboard and stand are included, while the tablet is around the same weight. That gives it a denser feel.

One significant design difference is that the ThinkPad X1 Fold has a more aggressive folded hinge design, with the folded halves lying flat against each other rather than sporting a gap, as with the other machines. The result is that the Lenovo is thinner when folded, at 0.69 inches versus the HP’s 0.84 inches.

There’s a catch, though — unlike the HP’s, the ThinkPad X1 Fold’s keyboard can’t be stored inside. The ThinkPad’s stand is also a separate component, whereas the HP and Asus stands are built into the tablet portion. The result is that with the ThinkPad X1 Fold, the keyboard and stand must be carried separately or attached magnetically to the bottom of the folded display. That makes for a thicker and arguably less convenient package.

The ThinkPad X1 Fold is just 0.34 inches thin as a tablet, which is thinner than the Asus Zenbook Fold 17’s 0.61 inches and around the same as the HP Spectre Foldable PC’s 0.33 inches. The Lenovo is more comfortable as a tablet, given its smaller dimensions, but that’s not saying a lot. A 16.3-inch tablet is quite large to use in hand and is best when laid out on a surface.

That makes the active pen easier to use for inking, and the ThinkPad X1 Fold is no more comfortable than the HP or Asus in tablet mode. Lenovo highlights using the ThinkPad X1 Fold as a large reading device, with the display partly folded, but I found that format cumbersome. The ThinkPad’s hinge required more force to open than I remember needing with the HP, and the HP felt more balanced on each side of the fold.

In clamshell mode, with the keyboard lying on the bottom half of the fold, the ThinkPad X1 Fold wasn’t as comfortable to use. The keyboard layout is more cramped, although the keycaps are large and feature the ThinkPad’s iconic sculpted design with the usual TrackPoint nubbin for those who like to use it.

The keyboard switches are light and snappy, which is great, but I preferred typing on the HP Spectre Foldable PC’s keyboard a lot more with its more spacious layout. The Lenovo’s clamshell display is also smaller, around 12 inches. Some screen is lost to the fold, which in clamshell mode forms a curve between the top of the display and the keyboard.

At the same time, Lenovo built a haptic touchpad into the keyboard, and while it’s smaller, it benefits from enabling clicks over its entire glass surface. The haptic mechanism is fast and offers natural-feeling clicks, and I liked it quite a bit better than HP’s mechanical touchpad. My only problem was that the keyboard goes to sleep after a few minutes and you have to press a key to wake it up. I usually tap a laptop’s touchpad, and I had to break some muscle memory.

The final piece of the ergonomic puzzle is desktop mode, with the tablet portion propped up using the stand and the keyboard sitting in front. As mentioned above, the ThinkPad X1 Fold’s stand is a separate component rather than being built in. It magnetically adheres to one edge of the tablet in landscape and one edge in portrait, and I found it problematic. First, it’s another piece to carry around, and it adds bulk. Second, you have to choose your edges carefully.

If you accidentally try to prop the tablet up along the wrong edge, it won’t adhere, and you’ll test your reflexes trying to catch it from falling. I did that a couple of times and quickly learned my lesson. Unfortunately, it doesn’t work that well, even when you’re attaching to the correct edge. Fortunately, I was lucky, and it never slid off my desktop. The HP and Asus featured built-in stands that avoid this menace.

Physically, then, I found the ThinkPad X1 Fold less comfortable to use in two of its three modes, clamshell and desktop, and no better in tablet mode. None of the foldable PCs I’ve used were great to use as a clamshell without the physical keyboard, given the unsuitability of a software keyboard for typing anything other than short text.

The HP Spectre Foldable PC has a mode where the keyboard sits on the bottom two-thirds of the folded tablet and adds a second screen, and that’s missing on the Lenovo.

Tablets are thin devices and, as such, can’t fit in legacy ports like USB-A and HDMI. The ThinkPad X1 Fold is no different, and it offers just USB-C ports with and without Thunderbolt 4. Lenovo also skips a 3.5mm audio jack, which is always unfortunate, and there’s also no SD card reader. The Asus includes an audio jack, and neither has an SD card reader.

So, the Lenovo’s a mixed design. The tablet charges via USB-C, as does the keyboard. The pen that was included in my review configuration uses batteries. On the HP Spectre Foldable PC, the keyboard and pen charge magnetically when attached to the tablet.

The ThinkPad X1 Fold uses a 16.3-inch OLED panel with an almost square 4:3 aspect ratio and a 2560 x 2024 resolution. That’s sharper than both the Asus and HP foldable PCs and just sharp enough to avoid obvious pixels in text. The aspect ratio makes for a more comfortable tablet while making the clamshell display quite small.

According to my colorimeter, the display was brighter than most OLED screens at 438 nits, and it had the technology’s usual perfect blacks and inky contrast. Its colors weren’t as wide as most, at just 93% of AdobeRGB, where most OLED displays are closer to 100%, and its color accuracy was just okay at a DeltaE of 1.52 (most are under 1.0).

Overall, the ThinkPad X1 Fold was an excellent visual experience for productivity and media consumption. The display supports Dolby Vision high dynamic range (HDR) video, but I was unusually unimpressed when running Netflix HDR content. Dark scenes weren’t as detailed as is typical with the format, which was an unpleasant surprise.

Audio is provided by two speakers on the edges of the tablet. In clamshell mode, they point to the sides, while in landscape desktop mode, one speaker is firing up, and the other is firing down and muffled by the stand. Overall sound quality was good but not great, with clear mids and highs but zero bass.

The ThinkPad X1 Fold uses Intel 12th-gen low-power CPUs, with options for vPro technology that can plugged into enterprise security and management systems. I tested with the Core i7-1250U, the same 10-core (two Performance and eight Efficient), 12-thread CPUs used in the HP Spectre Foldable PC and the Asus Zenbook Fold 17. These are 9-watt chips that meet the efficiency requirements and aren’t currently available in Intel’s 13th- and 14th-gen chips.

As I used the ThinkPad X1 Fold, I was constantly disappointed in one aspect or another. The stand wasn’t reliable, which is a very bad thing when it’s meant to prop up a tablet that starts at $2,499. Lenovo’s Yoga Book 9i has a much more complicated origami stand that holds that dual-display 3-in-1 firmly in place. So, Lenovo knows how to get it right and just didn’t. I also found the clamshell mode too small and, without its keyboard, too hard to use.

Performance was better than the other two foldable PCs we’ve used, but battery life was worse. The Asus Zenbook Fold 17 is less expensive with a reasonable configuration. The ThinkPad X1 Foldable isn’t the best option among today’s leading foldable PCs.

Editors’ Recommendations